Apple's Opaque ATT

Apple’s privacy changes—especially App Tracking Transparency (ATT)—didn’t stop tracking so much as break one of the main pipes used to connect identity across apps.

That forced ad networks (including Meta and others) to rebuild their systems around weaker, more indirect signals.

Here’s what actually changed.

1) What ATT actually did

App Tracking Transparency requires apps on iOS to ask:

“Allow this app to track your activity across other companies’ apps and websites?”

If the user says no, the app cannot access the IDFA (Identifier for Advertisers).

That matters because IDFA used to be:

• a stable device-level advertising ID

• shared across apps

• resettable but persistent enough for long-term tracking

So ATT effectively:

• cut off the easiest cross-app identity connector on iPhones

2) What got broken (significant disruption)

A) Cross-app tracking collapsed

Before ATT:

• App A knows you installed App B

• Both apps can share the same advertising ID

• Ad networks stitch behaviour together easily

After ATT (if user opts out):

• no shared IDFA

• apps can’t directly recognise the same device across apps

👉 This severely weakened:

• behavioural profiling across apps

• ad retargeting across different apps

• deterministic mobile identity graphs

B) Attribution became less precise

Ad platforms could no longer reliably answer:

“Did this ad on App A lead to purchase in App B?”

So measurement shifted from:

deterministic tracking → probabilistic estimation

C) Identity graphs lost a major “hard link”

Companies like Meta Platforms relied heavily on mobile cross-app identifiers.

ATT removed one of the cleanest edges in their identity graph:

• fewer direct device-to-device links

• more guesswork needed

What DIDN’T get broken

This is the important part.

A) First-party data is untouched

If you log into:

Instagram

Facebook

YouTube

Google services

Tracking still works because:

• identity is known at the server level

• no advertising ID is needed

So logged-in tracking remains extremely strong.

B) On-device signals still exist

Even without IDFA:

• device model

• OS version

• IP patterns

• app usage behaviour

• time-based signals

..still allow probabilistic matching.

So systems moved from:

“we know it’s the same device”

to:

“we’re 80–95% sure it’s the same device”

C) Web tracking still works outside apps

ATT only affects apps on iOS.

So:

• Safari browsing

• desktop browsing

• non-iOS devices

still use:

• cookies (where allowed)

• fingerprinting

• login-based identity

D) “SKAdNetwork” replaced direct tracking (partially)

Apple introduced SKAdNetwork, which:

• reports conversions in aggregate

• delays and anonymises data

• limits user-level visibility

But:

It still allows basic attribution just with reduced precision and delay

How ad companies adapted (the big shift)

After ATT, companies like Google and Meta shifted strategy:

A) From deterministic → probabilistic matching

Before:

“This exact device clicked and purchased”

Now:

“This group of devices likely includes converters”

They rely more on:

• statistical modelling

• aggregated signals

• machine learning inference

B) Heavier reliance on first-party data

Companies now push:

• login systems

• email-based identity

• account ecosystems

Because:

if users log in, ATT doesn’t matter

C) Server-side tracking increased

Instead of browser/app sending everything:

• websites send events directly to ad servers

This avoids some OS-level restrictions.

D) More fingerprinting and modelling (indirectly)

Even though Apple restricts fingerprinting:

• some signals still exist in aggregate

• ad networks rely more on “behavioural similarity” than device IDs

The net effect (important summary)

ATT:

• broke cross-app deterministic tracking on iOS

• reduced precision of ad attribution

• forced industry-wide redesign of mobile advertising

But did NOT eliminate:

• identity graphs

• behavioural profiling

• logged-in tracking

• cross-device inference

• household-level modelling

Before ATT:

“We track the device directly”

After ATT:

“We infer the device probabilistically from weaker signals”

So the system didn’t stop tracking—it became:

less exact

more statistical

more reliant on large-scale modelling

App Tracking Transparency didn’t kill tracking—it removed the cleanest identifier, forcing companies like Meta Platforms and Google to shift from deterministic identity to probabilistic identity graphs.

Comments

Shrunken Heads

Shrunken Heads: Ancient Ritual, Misunderstood Tradition, or One of History's Darkest Mysteries? Few historical artefacts provoke as much fascination as a shrunken human head. Displayed in museums, featured in adventure novels and immortalised in countless films, these remarkably preserved heads have long been associated with mysterious jungle tribes, forgotten rituals and supernatural powers. For many people, they represent one of the most unsettling objects ever created—a physical reminder of cultures that seemed to blur the line between life, death and the spiritual world. But behind the sensational stories lies a far more complex reality. Shrunken heads were not created simply as trophies of violence, nor were they originally intended to frighten outsiders. They formed part of a deeply held spiritual tradition that developed over generations among certain Indigenous peoples of the Amazon rainforest. At the same time, their rarity and mystery gave rise to an international trade ...

Interesting coffee-time reads

Looking for some coffee time reads? Read about how we don't live on a planet at all, we actually live on an old sun ...hence why everyone worshipped it. Feeling peckish? Maybe read about The Man Who Ate Uranium ....simply to see what happened. Spoiler alert: he's dead. Get yourself clued up on how to take out rogue robot soldiers . Or learn why cartels love employing ex-Special Forces personnel. Have a mid-life crisis in your lunch break when you realise all humans are part of a battery array being emotionally harvested to power something even bigger. Turn a piece of paper into a castle? Easy . Become a spy . Tell God to stop dicking about with all the buttons, realise how much water it takes to chat with an algorithm, or maybe just learn why democracy is the same as being ruled by continuous bias. Democracy, pah. That's so old hat, old boy. Learn who is going to die first with the Nuclear Weapon League Tables . Then try and sue the media for making you a nervous ...

Pharmaceuticals In Britain's Rivers

The Medicines We Leave Behind: How Pharmaceuticals Are Entering Britain's Rivers Every Day Every day across the United Kingdom, millions of people take prescription medicines to control blood pressure, treat infections, manage diabetes, ease pain, reduce depression, prevent seizures and improve countless other medical conditions. These medicines save lives, improve quality of life and form one of the greatest achievements of modern healthcare. Yet few people consider what happens after the medicine has done its job. The answer begins not in a pharmacy or hospital, but in the human body. Many medicines are only partially absorbed before being processed by the liver and kidneys. Depending on the drug, a significant proportion may leave the body in urine either unchanged or as metabolites—chemical by-products created during metabolism. Every flush of a toilet begins a journey through the nation's sewer network toward wastewater treatment works and, ultimately, Britain's rive...

Best Privacy Sunglasses to Protect Your Identity from Facial Recognition

Best Privacy Sunglasses to Protect Your Identity from Facial Recognition In today’s world, facial recognition cameras are becoming increasingly common—from airports and stores to city streets. While technology offers convenience, it also poses privacy risks. One simple step to protect your identity in public is wearing privacy sunglasses. From budget-friendly options to high-tech infrared-blocking glasses, the market has a variety of solutions designed to help obscure your face and reduce AI detection. In this guide, we’ll cover top-rated privacy sunglasses, explain how they work, and highlight features that matter most for protection. How Privacy Sunglasses Work Privacy sunglasses can protect your face in two main ways: • Visual Occlusion – Large frames, mirrored lenses, or fit-over designs hide key facial features from cameras. • Infrared or Reflective Lenses – Specialized coatings block or reflect infrared light, which some facial recognition systems use to scan faces. ⚠️...

The Pharaoh's Curse

The Pharaoh's Curse: Coincidence, Ancient Warning, or Something Beyond Explanation? For more than a century, one story has captured the imagination of historians, archaeologists and lovers of the mysterious alike. It is a tale of hidden tombs, unimaginable treasures, unexplained deaths and an ancient warning said to protect the resting places of Egypt's kings. It has become known simply as the Pharaoh's Curse. To some, it is little more than a sensational newspaper invention designed to sell headlines during the excitement surrounding one of archaeology's greatest discoveries. To others, the remarkable chain of deaths and misfortunes that followed the opening of several Egyptian tombs cannot be dismissed so easily. Whether viewed through the lens of history, science or the supernatural, the legend of the Pharaoh's Curse remains one of the world's most enduring mysteries. The Discovery That Changed Everything Although stories of cursed tombs existed long before ...

Bigfoot: The World's Most Successful Introvert

Bigfoot: The World's Most Successful Introvert There are celebrities who spend millions trying to stay in the public eye. Then there's Bigfoot, who has single-handedly managed to become internationally famous whilst refusing to pose for one half-decent photograph. Every celebrity today has a social media team, a publicist, and at least three apologies drafted in advance. Bigfoot has none of those things, he has one blurry picture from the 1960s yet an entire merchandising empire. If Bigfoot ever hires a marketing consultant, the meeting will last about thirty seconds; "What's your strategy?" "I don't show up." The mystery of Bigfoot has fascinated people for generations. Hunters search forests. Scientists debate evidence. Television crews spend weeks camping in the wilderness with expensive night-vision cameras. Somehow, the only creature they seem to film is Dave from production. He's basically the ninja of North America (not Dave, Bigfoot). ...

Cave 1Q: The Planted Scrolls?

Cave 1Q: The Planted Scrolls? The people who first discovered the Dead Sea Scrolls were not archaeologists or scholars. The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered by a group of Bedouin shepherds living in the Judean Desert in 1947. They were found near the ancient settlement of Qumran, on the northwest shore of the Dead Sea. The most famous discovery story involves a young Bedouin shepherd, often identified as Muhammad edh-Dhib, who was searching for a lost goat. According to the traditional account, he threw a stone into a cave and heard pottery breaking. Investigating, he found ancient jars containing leather scrolls. The first discoverers: Bedouin shepherds near Qumran The traditional discovery story begins in 1947 among the Ta'amireh Bedouin, a tribal group that lived in the area around the Judean Desert. The person most often credited with finding the first cave is: Muhammad Ahmed el-Hamed , commonly known as Muhammad edh-Dhib ("Muhammad the Wolf"). He was a young Bedouin...

Zombies: Do they exist?

Zombies: Do They Exist? The zombie has become one of the most enduring monsters in modern culture. Whether it's the relentless hordes of Night of the Living Dead, the infected masses of 28 Days Later, or the fungal nightmares of The Last of Us, the basic idea remains the same: a human loses their mind, becomes driven by instinct alone, and often spreads the condition to others. It's terrifying because it feels just believable enough. But do zombies actually exist? The answer depends entirely on what you mean by the word "zombie." If you mean the walking dead—corpses that rise from the grave and roam in search of human flesh—then science offers a straightforward answer: no. Once the brain dies, its cells begin to deteriorate within minutes. Muscles lose their energy supply, organs cease functioning, and decomposition begins. There is no known biological process capable of restoring a dead human body to coordinated movement. However, if a zombie is defined as a livin...

Protecting Your Privacy Online: The Complete Guide

How facial recognition generally works (high level) Modern systems analyze patterns like distances between facial features, texture, and contours. They often use multiple camera angles and can still function under partial occlusion or low lighting. That’s why simple “tricks” people mention online are often unreliable in practice. Lawful ways to protect your privacy If you’re concerned about surveillance in your area, there are more constructive approaches: Know your rights : Privacy and surveillance laws vary by country. In the UK, rules around CCTV and biometric data are governed by data protection laws and oversight bodies. Advocate and engage : Organizations like Privacy International campaign for limits and transparency around surveillance tech. Digital privacy hygiene : Managing how your images are shared online (social media settings, tagging, public profiles) can reduce how widely your face is indexed in datasets. Public accountability : Supporting policies that require au...

Earth: The Fossil Sun Theory

Earth: The Fossil Sun Theory. A remnant stellar body captured into the orbit of a younger sun Modern cosmology explains the Solar System as the product of a collapsing molecular cloud, forming the Sun and a rotating protoplanetary disk from which planets accreted. Yet there remain unresolved anomalies in planetary composition, orbital resonances, and internal heat distribution that leave room—at least in theoretical exploration—for alternative formation pathways. One of the more unusual but internally consistent speculative models is the Fossil Sun Theory, which proposes that Earth is not a conventional planet formed from disk accretion, but instead the remnant core of a previous stellar body that cooled, crusted over, and was later gravitationally captured into orbit around the current Sun within a former binary system configuration. This model attempts to account for several persistent observational puzzles through a single historical reconstruction: that Earth is a stellar remn...

Blurs

Search This Blog